In: Blog
16 Nov 2009I don’t like to judge people, but i will. I will judge them on their squat.
The squat is touted as the most fundamental movement on earth and about as functional as it gets. So why is it that people A) don’t know how to do it, and B) don’t place the emphasis that it deserves.
Now, don’t worry i am judging everyone when i watch them squat. I can tell how advanced an athlete is by their squat depth and mechanics as well as their potential. I can judge a coaches understanding of the squat by watching them teach it, and i can judge the knowledge the coach by watching how his clients or athletes squat. If you peak into a CF gym and see people making an effort to fix their squat with both hands on training from the coach and feedback from others in a class then you know that gym is legit. I like it when responsibility is placed in the hands of others for their progress.
Conversely i can tell a poor coach by the unwillingness to work on fundamentals on a daily basis till they are perfect. The consistently poor movement patterns will not only decrease athletic potential but also lead to more serious injuries.
Its worth it to work the squat. If you are a good coach, you should be able to convince your clients that its worth it as well. Everything else gets better as the squat improves.
To answer the questions above, A) In my opinion, ignorance. I am not saying this to be mean as i know you don’t mean to be ignorant and you sometimes feel that you might get bored with the squat, but take it as encouragement to gain a better understanding of it. Show people that it is important to you and work diligently to make yours perfect. Like i said, everything else will get better as your squat mechanics improve. If you read alot about powerlifting you will know that they place a huge focus on technique as any slight deviation from perfect will affect the weight you can lift. I would say that it is up to you which type of squat you want to use but i believe for a Crossfitter the upright torso, deep squat is best for the development of an athlete. Thats just my opinion and i don’t want to argue that. I have my reasons, if you want to know them come to a seminar.
B)In Crossfit, there is so much that we have to practice and get better at that it is maddening to think about spending 6-8 weeks focused on something as simple as the squat. Don’t be stupid! Its time well spent. Do it and you will see the results immediately.

11 Responses to Judgement Time!
Bill
November 16th, 2009 at 10:16 am
That is a Righteous and True judgment. After so much squat-centric attention, I cannot sit or even walk without awareness of my posterior chain.
Louise Smith
November 16th, 2009 at 10:35 am
What a great way to sort through Crossfit boxes!! Thank you for another amazing article!
Jay Ashman
November 16th, 2009 at 10:59 am
Dutch, when I was at a Strength Coach seminar in Boston I had the chance to take some high school girls through a workout. Well when I was teaching the proper squat mechanics some “top coach” told me not to worry it that much and her knees being far over her toes was ok…
I almost shit, this is a “top coach” and pretty well known in his area and I was doing my best to teach these 4 girls the proper mechanics. 3 of them picked it up fast, one had issues, so when I was taking her aside to show her some cues that’s when he stepped in and pretty much told me that it doesn’t matter because she was ok.
Needless to say, we argued about that and I reiterated that I am a “form nazi” and I don’t really want to teach bad form…
Long story short, pissed me off… and now he has a “hybrid muscle” book out for sale online that almost rips off CrossFit methods and even has a FAQ asking a question “Is this program like CrossFit” and calls his program superior….
Wow that was a rant…. ha
Josh
November 16th, 2009 at 11:06 am
Awesome Article! So no Low-Bar Back squat ever? Just curious…
And I have been wanting to go to your seminar for a long time!
But I am a poor college student.
When are you coming within 3-4 hours of the western part of NC?
Josh
November 16th, 2009 at 11:15 am
Oh yeah and a couple people who train with me have really unflexible hamstrings and cannot go to parrallel without “butt-winking” or I guess unactivating there hamstrings and rounding there back.
I have them do air squats instead and we do PNF stretching a lot, instead of doing weighted back squats.
But is it better to go as far as they can while keeping everything anatomically correct and doing weighted squats? Or do what I do and have them work on flexibility and air squats while keeping everything activated?
Thanks!
Jay Ashman
November 16th, 2009 at 11:37 am
And as a side note… I do low bar squats, but I also do a lot of front squatting as well, so I do believe I get the best of both worlds.
Jacob "BullFrog" Tsypkin
November 16th, 2009 at 10:10 pm
Outstanding post Dutch.
Jay Ashman
November 17th, 2009 at 9:00 am
Yes it is Jacob… Fundamentals are the key to success.
Clayton
November 17th, 2009 at 10:59 am
Dang Dutch, just beat me down why don’t ya. good Post, keep us honest, with ourselves and the people we train.
Elia
November 17th, 2009 at 11:35 am
Fact. Squats cure cancer.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nppzGV1U8y8
Ddeaton
November 18th, 2009 at 9:18 pm
Good stuff Dutch! Most athletes don’t understand that the squat is limited by the lack of constant attention to appropriate neural engrams.