In: Blog
28 Apr 2009I was talking to my mom the other day while she was in town. She was telling me about all the new stuff going on in health and Physical Education. She is a professor at ATM and has been a teacher educator for 30 plus years. She is also quite a crossfitter. She was in town for a planning meeting for TAAHPERD. She is on the board that decides on presenters for the annual conference.
There is an interesting topic coming up this year that has never been brought up in the past. Now that the ADA recognize morbid obesity as a handicap there must be accomodations made for children that are obese or morbidly obese. She did not elaborate on the details of the actual accomodations but that is not what i want to talk about. My issue is with the classification of obesity as a handicap.
Obesity is one of the leading preventable causes of death worldwide! (sorry for not citing this, my first reaction was to cite it then i thought…Fuck it, its my blog…haha). Luckily the FDA has not approved any drug interventions for children but there is an increasing number of teenagers getting gastric bypass and other elective surgeries. Currently the only intervention approved is life style and behavioral techniques.
There was a case recently at Texas ATM where a student sued the school because she was bruised pretty badly from the desks. She did not fit properly because of her obesity. She won the law suit citing the ADA recognition of obesity as a handicap.
Another story my mom told me was about one of her students. His kid brought home a permission slip to go to Gatti Town for an educational field trip. Wait, it gets better. It was a nutritional outing. The kids were supposed to learn about portion size and nutrients. Really? At an all you can eat buffet?? That is lazy and irresponsible on the schools part.
Back to the point… Now that health and physical educators have to make allowances for obese children the children will be excused from activities that are unsafe for them. This probably means any calisthenics, running, or anything with their feet off the floor. I remember in my PE class we had a rope that had to be 25 ft and we weren’t allowed to climb it if the mat wasn’t down. The mat was about 2 inches thick and harder than the floor. My have times changed!!
I understand the safety issue but if we limit these obese kids to the activities left they will never have a chance. I would rather expose them to some more activity and run the risk of injury. Honestly kids are made of rubber so if anything did get seriously injured they would bounce back pretty quickly. How many of you had broken bones as a kid??
You might wonder why i am not yelling and cursing in this post like i should be. The reason is simple. It isn’t the teachers fault these things come about. It isn’t even the kids fault. I feel like kids are high jacked from an early age and sent down a path of obesity and unhealthiness. Kids follow their parents actions and we all know where this is going. It is a sad state and i don’t have an answer to it other than doing your part to pass your knowledge and passion for activity on to your kids. Feed them paleo food and kick them out of the house to play with their friends.

12 Responses to Obesity is a Handicap!?!
Eric O
April 28th, 2009 at 1:50 pm
Nice post Dutch. I’ve seen a little of this in my PE Classes: the kids just seem to be getting bigger and bigger. Luckily, I have no restrictions and these kids can end up pretty exhausted after class.
I totally agree with you that the kids follow their parents actions and the parents are mostly responsible, educators can only do so much in the limited amount of time they are with us. On another note, I find it amazing when kids come back from vacations/weekends and all they can tell me that they did was play video games. I’m starting to feel that kids getting outside and playing all day will become a thing of the past…..that’s sad!!
dutch
April 28th, 2009 at 3:09 pm
Maybe it just skips a generation. My kids will be locked outside.
Eric, i think your story is awesome if you ever want to share it. maybe i could do an interview with you about this topic…
Josh
May 5th, 2009 at 10:46 pm
Dutch,
Just started reading your blog after Garrett turned me onto it.
Wanted to say thanks for this blog in particular, it really touched a nerve. I absolutely think that is ridiculous and it sickens me that it is true (the ADA declaration that obesity is a handicap). In fact, I think it is huge slap in the face to legitimately handicapped people.
While googling this particular subject I found this quote from another guy, “Diet and excersize won’t make a paralyzed man able to walk again, but it sure will solve the handicap of obesity.”
Awful what our society has become.
Lee
May 13th, 2009 at 10:31 am
Dutch,
Very sad article indeed. I could write a VERY long post on my thoughts about this subject but I am at work and well, need to get to work.
Let me add this though; about a year ago we moved from suburbia to the country. In suburbia my kids were actually not that active. Even when they go over to a friends house they usually end up inside. They may “play” for a bit but typically end up in front of the TV or playing videos.
Since we have moved to the country…they are different kids! We live in an area where there is a large concentration of Dutch people and a lot of them do not even own TV’s and computers are highly regulated. The result is that my kids are NEVER INSIDE! and when we call them to do homework, or shower or go to bed we get the biggest complaints.
They play all the good ‘ol games of Capture the Flag or Manhunt and some others that they have made up. They are building forts in trees, they are getting cuts and scraps, they are learning about life and death with insects and small animals, they are learning how to use a hammer and saw.
They are lifting things up and down, climbing, throwing, running, pushing, pulling….holy shit!!! that sounds like Crossfit.
My kids look better, feel better, sleep better and have good grades.
Kinda speaks for itself.
Kids, get outside.
Lee
bodydetoxdiet
August 3rd, 2009 at 7:52 pm
lots of americans and europeans are getting obese these days because of over-eating. people should be controlling what they eat or they should workout their body to burn fat.
vlad
August 9th, 2009 at 10:54 am
do you think obese people deserve an extra seat on the plane?
acnesolutions health site
September 13th, 2009 at 12:43 am
the best solution for obesity is none other than Exercise and Proper diet. i would try to avoid slimming pills or fat burning food supplements
~ melatonin side effects
September 26th, 2009 at 8:19 am
i was obese a few years ago but now i have reduced my weight by diet and exercise.
| Arthritis pain relief
October 8th, 2009 at 7:42 pm
Obesity is really a bad condition to be with. it is the cause of cardiovascular disease and diabetes. i always see to it that i have a healthy diet and a good exercise to avoid being overweight.
Jimmy Cruz
March 28th, 2010 at 7:58 am
here in Philippines, obesity is also becoming a problem. More and more children are getting obese due to a lifestyle that is not fully of physical activities. most kids just wants to watch TV, play computer games and surf the net.
Gelly Anderson
April 7th, 2010 at 1:54 am
Obesity and diabetes are becoming more and more of a problem these days. Actually it is easy to avoid being overweight by just having the proper diet and exercise.
Madeline Morgan
April 28th, 2010 at 12:48 am
more people are becoming obese these days because of too much junk food and too much sugar in snacks and fast foods.”